Momtourage > Need Advice? > My 4-year-old cries when he loses. Should I toughen him up?

SEARCH Q&As

Janine
Sarna-Jones
The Organizer
Bio
View Questions
Eileen
Behan
The NutritionistBio
View Questions
Natalie
Gahrmann
The Life Coach Bio
View Questions
Curt Hinson
The Child Fitness Expert
Bio
View Questions
Tanya Remer
Altmann
The Pediatrician
Bio
View Questions
Andrea Messina
The Practical Mom
Bio
View Questions
Denene Millner
The Real-Talk Mom
Bio
View Questions
Cindy Post Senning
The Etiquette Expert
Bio
View Questions
Marilyn Augustyn
The Behavioral Pediatrician
Bio
View Questions
THE QUESTION :

My 4-year-old son started crying when he lost his seat playing musical chairs at a birthday party. Should I try to toughen him up?
 
THE ANSWER:

The problem may be with the game, not your child. After all, we teach kids to share—except when you play a game like this. Then you’re supposed to push kids out of the way so you can be first.


Well, I like to teach the game a little differently. I call it Musical Shares. You put a bunch of hula hoops on the floor; at first, there are more hoops than kids. Each time the music stops, you take away a hoop. When there are more kids than hoops, the kids have to share a hoop. Eventually, you might have as many as 10 kids in a hoop. To make it work, they have to cooperate, solve problems, maybe even hug each other.


Duck Duck Goose is a similar elimination game. These are what I call “focus on failure” games. You want everyone to have a turn, so if there are 25 kids playing for 30 minutes, it means each kid gets to run around the circle for maybe six seconds. You’re sitting for more than 29 minutes. No much exercise there. And for each turn there’s one winner and one loser; the loser gets to sit in the middle, and so everyone knows that Johnny was the loser.


Instead, I play Duck Duck Goose with two lines of kids facing each other, with a safety line 18 feet back. Everyone has a partner. One child taps the other on the shoulder and says, “Duck, duck,” and at some point, “Goose,” then runs away.  Her partner has to chase and try to tag her before she runs behind the safety line. Only the two partners know who won or lost each time--and it doesn’t really matter. Plus, everyone is playing at the same time, either chasing or running away. It’s more fun and more exercise, and it improves the children’s skills.



Curt Hinson
3 Comments
On August 18, 2008 2:38 PM
Jon said:

Losing is a tough thing to learn for a four year old. I favor the "everyone is a winner" approach at this age, and they'll learn more about winning and losing as they get older. Games I've played with my son at age 4, he loses interest if he doesnt win half the time.

On October 22, 2008 8:15 PM
Autumn said:

I have a hard time with the "everybody wins" mentality. Perhaps musical chairs isn't something to play with a 4-year old since they don't quite understand the concepts yet. But personally, I don't think it's wise to teach children that they'll always win. Even worse is teaching kids that if they don't win and "get bored" that that's OK. I think it's an excellent way to teach children persistance, patience, and for them to know that not everbody is great at everything...they need to find the things *they're* good at.

On January 17, 2009 11:56 AM
Derek said:

Are you kidding me? 1) The kids know who won, just ask them. 2) In order for there to be a winner, there must, by definition, be a loser. 3) Losing isn't dishonorable, not trying is. Finally, losing is much keener character builder than winning. Losing makes us face those things we didn't succeed at head-on. Do you even have kids? Is the precurser to the book, don't try so you never fail?

Leave a comment
Name


Email Address


URL


Remember personal info?

Comments (You may use HTML tags for style)



Type the characters you see in the picture above.



 
ARCHIVES
RSS
 
FEATURED MOM MOMENTS

Name inspiration comes when you least expect it.

She's not a little baby anymore.

Plastic bag disposal is easy and free!

ADVICE DIRECTORY
Behavior
Title

Expert Section | Expert Section | Expert Section | Expert Section | Expert Section | Expert Section | Expert Section | Expert Section | Expert Section | Expert Section